Flashback: 'I Capture The Castle' : The Non-Classic YA Classic
Posted by alli
I Capture the Castle isn't a young adult book per se, at least not as we now generally define the genre. Those categories really didn't exist in 1948 when it was written. However, it certainly has all the makings of a great young adult story with the perfect teen-age protagonist. It doesn't have the savvy modern characters or the fast pace of the YA fiction we read today, but what it's lacking in those departments it makes up for in heart and soul. The drama in Cassandra's life is very similar to those in most contemporary YA novels. Dysfunctional family, class, first love and the sheer agony of growing up are the daily challenges she labors over in her journal. Her descriptions of brand-new feelings, thoughts and discoveries are as fresh and new as any modern day storyteller, and that's what makes it so timeless.
Cassandra grows from a playful young girl into a thoughtful, sensible woman over the course an eventful year. Very straight forward is the telling of her families' life in their beautiful but old and dilapidated rented castle in the English country-side. They are growing poorer by the hour to everybody's terror except the man of the house, Cassandra's father. Mortmain, the mad genius, is a seemingly washed-up author whose last great work of literature was published almost a decade ago at the time of Cassandra's memoir. A central theme in the novel is Mortmain's writer's block and his questionable sanity. This weighs on Cassandra as does her sister Rose's unhappiness with their station in life. At one point in I Capture the Castle, Cassandra compares Rose and herself to the Bennett sisters of Pride and Prejudice. And besides the obvious British-isms and the oh-so-proper language, it does read like a Jane Austen novel.
The other central plot is your typical love triangle, but it's more like a square with a triangle inside of it…let me explain. One day at the castle the landlords show up. The Cottons are a wildly rich American family who at first are simply obsessed with Mortmain's celebrity as a writer. Soon though they become intertwined and equally fascinated with the whole family and love triangles, squares, and ovals abound. It's really fun: Rose wants nothing more than to escape their eccentric desperate life so she talks herself into falling for Simon, the wealthy eldest Cotton son, but she never really loves him. While he worships her, she's really falling for Neil, Simon's brother. Simon and Rose get engaged. Stephen, (he's essentially the adopted-super-hot-stable-boy-turned-model/actor…) has always been in love with Cassandra and professes his love over and over to her. She never reciprocates. She can't. She's in love with Simon….. and on and on. There's much more to these relationships than I can describe here, and a few more triangles to boot, but the main thing is how Cassandra processes and navigates in completely new emotional territory.
I think what I love best in I Capture the Castle is Cassandra's voice. I first read it in college and when I picked it up to re-read, I could completely hear her sweet, enthusiastic voice as clear as a bell in the very first line. It had the exact same musical quality I remembered liking so much — so endearing, so refreshing. She is an insanely likable narrator and tells a colorful and rich coming-of-age story. I'm not sure if this Dodie Smith novel is considered as much of a YA classic as her 101 Dalmatians is for children, but after re-reading it as such I think it should be.
Advertisement

















