NPR is doing a series about famous and memorable characters called, 'In Character'. Andrea Seabrook recently interviewed Tobias Wolff (Author, This Boys Life) and Stephanie Savage (Producer, 'Gossip Girls') about Holden Caulfield, the preppy protagonist from J.D. Salinger's seminal novel Catcher in the Rye. This was so fun for me to listen to. Catcher in the Rye is hands-down, my favorite book ever, and Holden is my all-time favorite character.
After being cut from the field hockey team (Honestly, I'm over it.) I joined the speech and debate team. For which, and anyone who knows me will agree, I was far better suited.
One wintry, early Saturday evening on the short-bus home from a "meet" I met a boy from another school. We must have partnered with a local team for some sort of far-away regional thing. I was sitting behind him and he kept turning around to talk to me. Finally, uninvited, he moved back to sit with me. He proceeded to tell me all about an affair that he had with one of his friend's mother. I didn't believe him but he was so sincere and serious about it, I pretended to. I think on some level I understood that for whatever reason, he really wanted to tell me about this. I very vividly remember the way he looked too. He had large features for a boy, and thick wavy light brown hair. He was wearing a Paddington-style wool coat with a hood. His style of talking was quiet but also somewhat aggressive. Slightly affected and overly mature, his story felt like a put-on to me. Ultimately, I felt pity for him.
Now that I'm a bona-fide grown-up and have seen a thing or two, I'm not sure he was lying about the affair. I also don't know if I read Catcher in the Rye before or after meeting him, but in my minds-eye, I have always imagined that boy as Holden Caulfield.
J.D. Salinger wrote Catcher in the Rye in a series of stories first published in The New Yorker in 1946. It was later published as a book in 1951. It was hailed by critics but also criticized for its sexual content and profanity. It was groundbreaking because as Savage put it, it arrived on the "cusp of an explosive time" for American youth. This was before teens had their own culture, before they were a demographic. It was pre-Elvis. Pre-James Dean in "Rebel Without a Cause." Many people consider Catcher in the Rye the first young adult novel, and Holden Caulfield the original teenager, especially if you consider how we know that population today. It was published in the New Yorker so it would seem that it was meant for adult readers. Does it matter? Salinger wrote from the POV of a teen, strictly seeing the world through Holden's eyes, which gave the book its authenticity and characteristic honest beauty. We meet Holden during a time in his life filled with great angst and drama, both true and exaggerated tragedy. So sensitively, Catcher in the Rye describes the crucial time in one's life when you become aware that things are changing. Childhood is coming to a close, yet maturity alludes you. Fear and panic about adulthood and the real world loom.
I decided after listening to the NPR piece that I was going to re-read Catcher in the Rye. Most of us were introduced to it as teenagers ourselves and while it remains one of the most censored titles, it is also one of the most assigned in high schools across the country. It's been many years, and I want to see how it feels to experience Holden with adult sensibilities. What can he teach me now? How have teens in literature changed, or not?
I encourage anyone to do this with me and post your before-and-after impressions and insights at Ypulse Books. As adults who read books for teens, I think this is an amazing exercise. I've re-read many favorite titles from my teenage years and it's really interesting to see what turns out to be different and new to me as an adult. More importantly, I think it's helpful to compare it with what we understood as a younger reader.